Holiday season can be a mixed blessing
Originally Published in the Cheese Reporter

 

Like the well used real estate declaration, location, location, location, marketing people have a philosophy that is like a self fulfilling prophesy.

I came to marketing from the back door. My career began on the operations side, managing restaurants and bakeries. Ten hours a day in front of blazing hot stoves and ovens left no room for cozy thoughts of marketing. My motto at the bakery was simple, you sell, and we’ll make it. Simple and tough. No room for fluffy marketing stuff.

Then, in the mid-1980’s a recession hit. Suddenly it wasn’t quite so easy to just go sell it. Our competitors had copied many of the unique products that we had developed. Our award-winning offerings were being blurred in the minds of the prospects. Many of the upscale bakery products began to look the same. 

How were we going to get and keep our customer’s attention? We did not. We never developed a Unique Selling Proposition that kept customers focused on our differences. We lost market share. Not being the low cost provider, we lost key customers to rivals who could make products very similar at a much better price. I ultimately left that company and went on to other opportunities but I learned the lesson. Marketing would have worked for that long-forgotten company. I became a believer in the value of marketing. 

Marketing is the process of creating a strategic demonstrable difference and then simply communicating the features, advantages and benefits of that difference to prospects. Good marketing should grease the skids for the sales team to open and close. Great marketing should be so powerful that customers come looking for you.

Does your company have such a 

good marketing approach that prospects understand your point of difference in one sentence? If not, your marketing isn’t working. Your company has three seconds to present its case to prospects. Nine-tenth’s of a second in direct mail. At these speeds, you had better be precise.

Whether we enter a recession now is unclear. What is clear is that the economy has slowed substantially. Consumer confidence, that psychological element that keeps consumers spending, has been shaken. Two-thirds of the US economy comes from consumers. Does your company have a killer-marketing plan? 

We have just left a time in the cheese industry of full production capacity. When factories are producing at the top end, marketing seems less important. As the economy throttles back, that will not be the case. This old production guy thought that gray area stuff was just fluff. Is your company production driven or market driven?

The cheese industry is notorious for being production driven. Many of the great cheese makers I have met just don’t have a clear understanding of how demand for their product is driven. They see their world through the eyes of production capacity. “We can process XX million pounds of milk a week.” With a great economy and an industry at or near full capacity, this had been enough. 

There are three super plants coming on line in California in the next 18 months. This additional industry capacity coupled with an economic slowdown could spell problems for less efficient plants without a strong marketing message. Now is the time to create or uncover that strategy and develop a Unique Selling Proposition.

Steps To Develop Your Marketing Plan

  • Assemble the key managers and explain the process and the need for honest feedback and information.
  • Assemble the key management numbers; sales, costs, profits, capacity utilization, throughput.
  • Assemble a sales analysis; number of customers, pricing, marketing programs, pricing to key customers, percentage of profitable sales, key lost customer list.
  • Analyze your top competitors: honestly list their strengths, weaknesses and your specific strategy toward each.
  • Analyze your strengths.
  • Honestly evaluate your weaknesses.
  • Discuss your short term, mid and long term problems.
  • List the assumptions you are making.
  • Discuss your critical issues.
  • List your opportunities and rank them.
  • Look at your current marketing plan. What is the current budget? What is working? Where do you need to improve? Who will you be targeting? How will you target them? What is the new budget required in order to accomplish those goals? How will additional budget be funded? Where can you raise additional funds?
  • Develop critical measuring tools to evaluate results.
  • Evaluate strategic marketing alternatives; advertising, research and surveys, direct mail, newsletters, recipe contests, point of sale, new product development, line extensions, strategic marketing alliances, trade show participation, development of more effective distributor programs, direct operator programs and new brand development are alternatives to consider.
  • Agree on decisions and implement.
  • Test and get feedback. Adjust where needed.
A key to successful marketing is the ability to honestly evaluate your current position and creatively develop disciplined strategies. Many companies don’t develop the long-term marketing that they need because the process is too long and short-term problems persuade them off the track. Focusing on long-term strategic marketing and executing the plan well will eliminate many long-term problems.

The food industry in general has been slow to embrace critical measuring tools for evaluating marketing program effectiveness. In foodservice, the lack of bar codes and scanners has withheld the vital sales information necessary to measure results. Therefore, most evaluations of marketing programs have been done on gut feel. 

You, your department, your company can design and implement disciplined effective marketing strategies. The first step is to recognize that marketing is important. Discipline comes from understanding marketing’s lack of urgency and keeping it a top priority.

Ed Zimmerman